When did the trouble begin Thomas R. Holtz jrAn expert at the Tyrannosaurus rex typified the rock unit “Hell Creek Formation” in Montana, where the remains of North America’s last giant dinosaur have been found.
He was trying to answer a colleague’s question after an online presentation during the first day Society of Vertebrate Paleontology80th Annual Conference.
But Mr. Holtz was rather shocked by the word “hell” when four asterisks appeared in the chat.
Surprised, he described the issue on Twitter. Colleagues cheated with other words that were set up by software systems to filter out defacement: knob, pubis, penetrate and stream, others.
“The funniest ‘bone’ for us was censorship, which is, after all, the main thing that works with us,” said Holtz.
Many have raised concerns about online censorship by large tech companies. Instagram Has been criticized To ban the posts of art featuring nudity. In 2016, the Swedish Cancer Society Graphics of square shaped breasts used To avoid Facebook’s censors in a video about breast censors.
But the blocking of benign words commonly used by paleontologists seemed particularly overzealous.
After Mr. Holtz Posted a list of banned words on Twitter, He received a series of responses.
Some users were angry.
“Pubic? Seriously? What are you going to say ???” LP Norman wrote, A self-described amateur astronomer. “Next to ischium bone ???”
Others tried to be helpful.
“Gettathesaurus,” One person wrote.
The Paleontology Conference, which attracts hundreds of scientists, amateur bone collectors and dinosaur enthusiasts each year, was scheduled to take place in Cincinnati. But the epidemic forced organizers to move it online, such as thousands of other trade shows, summits and professional conferences that were scheduled to be held in hotels and convention centers.
This meant holding sessions for panelists who were expected to make presentations in public, and developing an online code of conduct for participants to prevent any shameful conduct.
The society contracts with a software company that provides chat sessions with built-in algorithms that can filter out any profanity or derogatory terms.
“All software plug-ins are going to have filters, to make sure you don’t get out of control,” said Caroline Bradfield, Conway Services, Hired by the company society.
“In that particular case, the filter was too tight,” he said.
Ms Bradfield, who listened in 10 sessions, said she knew about the problem from the participants who were talking about it. She said that she was surprised like everyone else.
“I don’t know why the word ‘bon’ was in the world.”
Jessica Theodore, The society’s president, said participants continue to find other words that trigger an asterisk and alert society leaders, who then reported to Conway Services. The company quickly dropped the words as it learned about them.
Palaeontologists started having fun with the system.
They typed in random words to see which would result in an asterisk. One Created a meme that compares his efforts with those sociologists in the film “Jurassic Park”“That threw itself against an electric fence to find vulnerable places.
“A couple of us were amazed and started calling Hell Creek ‘Heck Creek’.” Stephanie K. Drumheller, A lecturer and paleontologist at the University of Tennessee.
Jack Tseng, A professor of paleontology at the University of California, Berkeley, said that some censored words were not amusing.
For example, Wang, a popular surname in China, was also replaced with an asterisk.
“I knew how Wang was used,” Professor Tseng said. “I went to high school.”
He was curious if Johnson, through another surname that could be used as a term for male genitalia, would make it through. For their downfall, the system allowed it.
“He was upset,” Professor Tseng said. “If you are going to censor, then censor everything. Everyone is angry then Censor Johnson. “
Ms Bradfield said she did not know why Wang was not caught by the algorithm by Johnson.
Conway Services used a third party – Arena.im – to provide technology that filters some words. But Ms. Bradfield said it was ultimately her company’s responsibility to ensure that it would avoid similar problems in the future.
The solution, he said, was straightforward.
“We have to make sure that we take that filter and remove words that are stupid and shouldn’t be,” she said.
Still, Professor Theodore, who teaches at the University of Calgary at the University of Alberta, Canada, said he was relieved at how easily the five-day conference was finally concluded.
“If that’s the worst thing that happens when we move our paleontology conference online, that’s fine,” she said.
Professor Tseng, who has been attending conferences since he was an undergraduate, led the episode to question him when he and his co-workers hear the sound, discussing knobs and bones out of context Huh.
“Maybe if you hear that a bunch of paleontologists talk in an area that seems very dirty,” he said. “And we don’t feel it.”